Police: Babysitter gave 8-month-old deadly dose of Benadryl

Published:
Updated:

Family photos show a baby with the biggest, bluest of eyes who was just starting to develop his personality.

"He was a happy baby,” Denise Mulkey said of her grandson Haddix. “He loved to be cuddled and held, like normal babies. He just loved to be cuddled.”

Today those photos are all Haddix's mother has left of him.

"I'll have to go see my baby at a cemetery. Not in my arms, at a cemetery,” Katie Mulkey said.

Police said Haddix and his sister were two of eight children Lori Conley was watching in her Reynoldsburg home.

Neighbors say on May 13, they saw Conley run into her yard hysterical. Haddix was in her arms, his face blue. He died that day at the hospital.

Reynoldsburg Police said at first it wasn't clear why a healthy baby suddenly died until they learned what Conley had given him.

"She told us it was Benadryl to try to get the baby to go to sleep,” Lieutenant Ron Wright said. “She was very vague on exactly how much, but she did give adult size dosages- the pills that are adult size dosages.”

Every box of Benadryl carries the warning: “Children under 6: DO NOT USE.”

Police say the autopsy found Haddix had brain swelling and fluid in his lungs. His cause of death: a drug overdose.

Friday morning Reynoldsburg Police arrested Conley on charges of murder and child endangering.

Lori Conley has been charged with murder in the death of an 8-month-old in her care.

"I entrusted her to take care of my son Haddix and my daughter while I worked to provide for my family," Katie Mulkey said.

His grandmother said there aren't words for their pain.

"Devastating as a parent because my daughter is broken,” Denise Mulkey said. “And since she is broken I can’t fix her. This is something that God can only fix.”

As for Conley, Denise said they are going to pray for her.

"I just really want justice for my baby,” Katie said. “Because this is something that was robbed from me, that was taken away."

Conley is in the Franklin County jail. Conley's family declined to comment, except to say she is an excellent mother.