The Ohio Insurance Institute (OII) compiled the following list of insurance company toll-freephone numbers and Web sites to assist with filing claims.
- Allstate Insurance: 800-547-8676 or online at www.allstate.com
- American Commerce Insurance Company: 877-224-5677
- American Family Insurance Group: 800-692-6326 (800-MYAMFAM)
- Auto Owners: 888-841-6473
- Buckeye Insurance Group: 800-672-3558
- Central Mutual Insurance Company: 888-263-2924 or online at www.central-insurance.com
- Century Surety Group: 800-878-7389 or online at www.centurysurety.com
- Cincinnati Insurance Company: 877-242-2544
- Citizens Insurance Company: 800-628-0250
- CNA Insurance Group: 800-588-7400
- Eastern Ohio Mutual Fire & Tornado Company: 877-658-3672
- EMC-Hamilton Mutual Insurance Group: 800-732-5595
- Erie Insurance Group: Canton area claims: 800-362-6541
- Columbus area claims 800-282-1702 or online at www.erieinsurance.com
- Farmers Insurance: 888-425-2467 or 800-435-7764 or online at www.farmersinsurance.com
- Farmers Mutual Relief Association: 800-456-0873
- FCCI Insurance Group: 800-226-3224 or online at www.fcci-group.com
- GEICO: 800-841-3000 or online at www.geico.com
- German Mutual Insurance Company: 800-597-0140
- Grange Insurance: 800-445-3030
- Liberty Mutual Group: 800-225-2467 or online at www.libertymutual.com
- Mennonite Mutual Insurance Company: 800-678-6885
- Motorists Insurance Group: 800-876-2576 or online at www.motoristsgroup.com
- Nationwide Insurance: 800-421-3535 or online at www.nationwide.com
- Ohio Casualty Group: 800-366-6446 or online at www.ocas.com
- Ohio Mutual Insurance Group: 888-895-7725 or online at www.omig.com
- Pike Mutual Insurance Company: 800-828-6559
- Progressive Insurance Group: 800-274-4499 or online at www.personal.progressive.com
- Springfield Township Mutual Insurance Association: 800-260-3379
- State Auto Insurance Companies: 800-766-1853 or online at www.stateauto.com
- State Farm Insurance: 800-732-5246 or online at www.statefarm.com
- Wayne Mutual Insurance Company: 800-222-3873
- West Bend Mutual Insurance Company: 877-922-5246
- Western Reserve Insurance Company: 800-362-0426
- Westfield Insurance: 800-243-0210