MOUNT VERNON, Ohio — Mount Vernon City Schools announced Tuesday that it will launch an independent investigation into
allegations made against an eighth-grade science teacher by parents.
According to a complaint, John Freshwater used an electrostatic device to burn crosses onto
students’ arms. One of the students said that the pain was so severe that it prevented him
from sleeping at night.
Attorney Jessica Philemon said her client was one of the students involved. She referred to
the student as John Doe, 10TV's Tanisha Mallett reported.
"The cross-burning happened during an eighth-grade science class," Philemon said. "It happened
with a science machine that uses an electric shock to cause a burn, and the teacher chose to burn a
cross onto John Doe's forearm."
Philemon said parents complained to the district after the alleged incident in December
2007.
10TV News reported last week that Freshwater agreed to take down the Ten Commandments from the
door of his classroom, along with posters containing Bible verses and Bibles on a shelf.
However, he refused to remove a Bible from his desk.
The complaint charges that Freshwater used his classroom to advance religion in violation of
the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment. In a recent class, it was charged that
Freshwater taught the meaning of Good Friday and Easter.
“The allegations against Mr. Freshwater are very serious,” said Steve Short, the school
superintendent. “This is not about his personal Bible on his desktop. It is about the
totality of his conduct.”
According to the district, there were also allegations that Freshwater conducted prayers and
engaged in a “healing session” as part of a Fellowship of Christian Athletes meeting.
After Freshwater acknowledged he may have engaged inappropriately as a participant rather than
monitor the meetings, Short directed the middle school principal to remove Freshwater as a
monitor.
Until the investigation concludes, Freshwater's classroom will be monitored, the district
said.
According to the Ohio Department of Education, there is no state rule or policy on religious
articles. It leaves the decision up to individual school districts to decide.
10TV obtained a copy of Mount Vernon's policy and it states that the district does not allow
"devotional exercises or displays of a religious character," Mallett reported.
Short said he was made aware the policy was being violated after a parent complained.
"The complaint involved the Ten Commandments and I believe eight to 10 Bibles that were
stacked on a shelf," Short said last week.
Previous Stories:
April 17, 2008:
Student Backs Teacher In Fight To Keep Bible On Desk
April 16, 2008:
Teacher Refuses To Move Bible From Desk
©2008 by 10TV.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.