Ohio Kicks Off Case Against Teenager Accused In Craigslist Slayings


Prosecutors say that 17-year-old Brogan Rafferty is a cold-blooded killer who used Craigslist to lure men to Ohio to take their lives.

On Friday, the one man who says he got away testified against Rafferty.

The focus of the trial, according to the prosecution, is to determine the role Rafferty played in killing three men and in the attempted murder of another.

"He is a student in robbery, deception and murder," said Emily Pelphrey, a special prosecutor with the Ohio Attorney General's Office.

But the defense said another man, Richard Beasley, is the monster in the case.

Prosecutors outlined how the victims had responded to Craigslist ads. They were looking for work in tough economic times.

Ralph Geiger, 56 of Akron; David Pauley, 51, of Virginia; and Timothy Kern, 47, of Massillon were all shot and killed. Prosecutors laid out the details in each of their deaths.

One man escaped Rafferty and Beasley. Scott Davis, 49, testified on Friday.

"It was going to be working on a cattle farm, bending fences, taking care of the animals," said Davis.

But Davis said a meeting with his prospective employees quickly turned dangerous.

"When we were going to go back to the road, I heard a cuss word and a gun cock," he said in court. "I knew I was in trouble."

He said he was shot in the elbow. He survived by running and hiding in the woods in southeast Ohio for seven hours.

The defense never denied that these deadly shootings happened.

What they did do is paint Rafferty as a scared teenager, succumbing to the mastermind of his mentor, Beasley. 

It will be up to the jury to decide just what part Rafferty played.

Watch 10TV News and refresh 10TV.com for continuing coverage.

Previous Stories:
April 18, 2012:
Boy, 17, To Be Tried As Adult In Connection With Craigslist Slaying
February 17, 2012:
Teen Pleads Not Guilty In Craigslist Slayings
December 1, 2011:
Friend: Phony Job Ad Was 'Tailor Made' For Craiglist Victim
December 15, 2011:
Teen In Craigslist Case Transferred To Adult Court
November 30, 2011:
Man Tied To Craigslist Investigation Charged With 15 Prostitution-Related Counts
November 29, 2011:
Letter From Craigslist Teen To Father: ‘I Hope You Can Forgive Me’
November 26, 2011:
Noble Co. Sheriff Confirms: Man’s Body Found
November 22, 2011:
Missing Man Could Be Tied To Craigslist Case
November 18, 2011:
Teen Arrested In Connection With Craigslist Slaying